Daniel,
Heh-heh, you're probably better off taking a ride someone's car who has done the upgrade, if only to feel and hear the difference.
Because it's pretty much already been confirmed in various posts (past and present) by those who have done the upgrade that yes, noise will be deeper and louder, no matter what exhaust system you have. And yes, performance will improve and the response to be quicker. This applies both to the 2.0t and the 2.5t.
So I'm not sure what else you're looking for or how many more people to say it's a worthwhile upgrade?
Don't worry, I was exactly the same not long ago. No matter how much people like Phil told me it was a great mod that will free up the power on the car, and it wouldn't increase noise levels that much, I still couldn't convince myself it was something I wanted. Mainly because I didn't want to lose the comfort and increase noise too much.
However taking a ride in Phil's car, I was finally convinced it was a worthwhile mod which would not corrupt the luxury feel of the Liberty.


This thread is about Phat GT's dump pipe. Heh-heh. 