by HyRax » Mon Nov 05, 2012 8:56 pm
I assume the OP is not looking at GT's because they are considerably more expensive to insure compared to a 2.0R or a 2.5i, and he has cited running costs as a pre-requisite. It's half the reason I've gone down from turbo to N/A myself.
But I digress. A quick squizz at Car Sales suggests that the newer 2007+ Liberty models are generally only available in automatic and/or sedan form up to $15K. In the Outback range, there are a lot more manuals to choose from but the K's are much higher as most of these cars inevitably are highway/holiday cars. In any case, you have a few options to choose from that IMO are better value than a 2.0R.
I would personally stick with Gen4 models (2004 to 2009). The "face-lift" models are from late 2007 to 2009. Apart from a cosmetic overhaul, the major reason you might want to look at 2007+ models is that they have a different ECU that allows for open-source tuning if you intend to look at modding later on, however in your case this may put you outside your $15K range.
However if the car is only going to be a standard daily driver, no mods and will not actually tow anything of significance like a caravan, a 2.0R should be fine, but if you are going to do a lot of mountain driving or any other regular uphill climb or regularly tow stuff, consider looking at a 2.5i model as they do have noticeably more torque for those applications and are really no more expensive than the 2.0R to insure and run.
I was going to procrastinate, but I put it off...