225 works fine. I'm using 225/45/18 on 18x8.5 +44 at stock height and stock camber. Stretch is not too bad. 235 should also work. 245 will definitely NOT work without guard flaring, but it does make for a perfectly straight sidewall.



Here's a couple of pics of 245/45/18 vs 225/45/18 rubber (both same make and brand - Kumho KU31) on identical 8.5" +44 rims (Rota Gravels). The 245 is on the left in each pic. The 225 is on the right. The sidewall stretch is quite visible on the 225.


Here's what the 245/45/18 rubber on an 8.5" rim looks like on the front of my car (stock height, stock camber) - it sticks out a lot. Naturally the 225 tucks in.

The sticking out is less obvious with 245 on the back, but it still sticks out a little, thus requiring flaring (pic wasn't exciting enough to be worth posting).
I was going to procrastinate, but I put it off...