coyote wrote:What do you want to achieve with the aftermarket controller?
I think you are better off letting the ecu control boost, but there may be something in particular that precludes you from doing that.
CJ1177 wrote:I know I would achieve a smoother boost response & have better control of the boost with out spiking
this becomes more apparent with the more boost you run.
I know what you are referring to, but it is a function of the cheap OE 2 port solenoid, not the fact that the ecu is controlling boost. An upgraded solenoid will give you all those things, without having to do it with a controller separate from the ecu.
CJ1177 wrote:I can easily change the level of boost at will mostly important when you leave the car with the service dept or valet parking.
Well that's a plus for the aftermarket controller as it is hard to do with an old ecu and limited with SI Drive. Having said that, better hope the service technicians don't know how to play with the boost controller. I had an experience many years ago whereby a young Subaru dealership mechanic took my car for a thrashing with the wastegate completely disconnected.
CJ1177 wrote:or on the recent HOT days, it is most important to be able to drop the boost at will. you need the confidence that you can put your foot flat to the floor & know that its not going to ping.
Hmmm... as Boxer said, that's a big plus for letting the ecu control boost. It will automatically compensate for temperature, detect any knock and adjust multiple parameters accordingly. If you are likely to do some damage, it will limit your boost to wastegate pressure only. You lose that with an aftermarket controller.
I'm not saying aftermarket controllers are crap, they are the only solution that lets you sit the car and randomly dial up how much boost you want today, but better spool, no spiking and rock solid control at high boost does not require losing all the protection the ecu offers.