Newbie GT wrote:bigBADbenny wrote:afaik similar, the VF52 will drop off a little less due to the slightly larger compressor, afaik

Sorry Benny but can a tuner set to say 18psi and have it not over boost more than that ?
Our ECU's run a PI controller (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PID_controller) for boost, you set boost targets and the control loop tries to hit those targets, but input disturbances upset the system (shit happens and can cause boost spikes. The closer you set your targets to mechanical limits (clamping force of head studs) or closer to running your actuators at full saturation (wastegate duty cycle close to 100%) the higher the risk.
In more general terms, you have a requirement - more power. Let your tuner arrive at the best practice way to meet this requirement. Don't specify a solution to your requirement (some aspirational boost target for whatever reason).